Thursday, November 13, 2008

Why I'm an Atheist

I was raised in a household by fairly open minded Christian parents who went to church in childhood but never took me to church. We celebrate Christmas and Easter as a family but otherwise religion was rarely discussed in detail in my home. I think I will always celebrate these holidays simply because they have a lot of family meaning to me even though I don't have any belief in the religious meaning behind them. I try to do this in the most respectful way possible.

When I was still very young I thought that Christianity didn't make sense to me. I didn't like the idea that in order to accept most any religion you had to say that billions of other people were wrong about their deeply held convictions. It seemed people would take on a religions simply because that is the background the had. This developed into a greater sense that other religions also didn't make sense to me for largely the same reasons.

I do remember, when I was very little, praying but not really understanding why a God with a plan would need to be swayed by verbalized prayers particularly if since he was all knowing he would know what I was going through, thinking, and feeling. I had trouble with the idea that a God would care about one sports team praying for an outcome harder than an other... or far worse that he would take sides in a war where lives were lost based on prayer. It seemed presumptuous to pray for the downfall of someone else.

Some of the things asked of us in the bible such as punishments for sins that weren't really noted by people nowadays confused me. Touching the flesh of a dead pig is punishable by death in the old testament. If the bible was the word of God why were people picking and choosing which parts they were choosing to live by?

I had trouble with the idea that some great all knowing wise being would be so absorbed in the small behaviors of individuals. So many things asked of human beings in the bible seemed vain and petty. It seemed less likely that man was created in God's image but that god was created in man's flawed, power driven, and patriarchal image. The fact that religion could be and was manipulated to control the masses seemed to make this all the more likely. Religion is the perfect way to establish order. What better way to ensure good behavior of the masses than to tell them that an invisible man in the sky is watching them and will damn them to a fiery eternity if they misstep even if no mortal man ever knows?

It interested me that so many cultures separated would come up with different religions. It seemed like mankind all over the world was trying to understand why they were there and how everything worked. Religion seemed like a perfect way to establish perfect order. What better way to ensure good behavior of the masses than to tell them that an invisible man in the sky is watching them and will damn them to a fiery eternity if they mistep even if no mortal man ever knows?

The lack of evidence on top of this was the worst. There are too many explanations that seem far more likely.

At a young age I then came to the conclusion that religion in general just wasn't something I could place any level of faith behind. There were too many inconsistencies.

I am an atheist. However, I personally am not comfortable saying that I believe there isn't a God. That takes a certain level of faith, however tiny, and while, "You can't prove he doesn't exist," is a horrible argument too often used to try to "disprove" or at least argue against atheism, I don't want to risk being fundamentalist in any direction. I don't want to risk being as close minded as so many people I am deeply offended and frustrated by. I never want to force my beliefs on someone else. I do however enjoy conversations on the topic if the other person is open to it.

I am an atheist not an agnostic (at least not in terms of being uncommitted to a particular world view). I have an absence of a belief in any form of deities. While I can't avoid saying it isn't an incredibly almost infinitesimal possibility I certainly don't believe there is a God.

2 comments:

Freethinker at large said...

Hello Realee. I got to your page via Stumble and I quite like it :).

I, like you, am reluctant to take the title "atheist." (Not so much the title itself, rather the connotations of its standings). To deny that a god could exist is not a legitimate way of thinking. However, given the way our world acts, it would be safe to live as though this god does not exist. I am without idea of God, seeing as I do not accept any canonized scripture as divinely inspired. There may be a god out there, but if there is, it is making no attempt to show or even necessitate its existence.

Now, if god were to show up tomorrow, I would certainly accept its existence. I may even worship it. Being able to say "I know of God" rather than having to say "I believe in God" means a lot to me. I can know that 1+1=2 (conversely, I merely believe that I am using a laptop to post this message), why should my perception of the ultimate consciousness, the creator of the universe no less, suffer any lesser classification of knowledge than that?

realee said...

1) @freethinker: Thank you that was a really thoughtful post and I'm sorry I didn't see it until years after you posted it through criminal levels of blog neglect. I agree with your representation of knowledge and belief and appreciate the distinction.

2) My years later additional thought to my post: Since this post I share the same definition and basically the same reasoning as I did in '08 although would say that I am *also* agnostic... given what we have as evidence I think it isn't possible to know there is a god. (If an being came to humanity and said "I created you and am a supreme being, your God" I'd want to know how, proof they did it, if I could believe that proof I'd still need clarification on what makes this creating/advanced/impressive being a God?... Complicated fast as I'm not sure how you'd prove that, advanced technology can look supernatural to those without it, but should we worship someone with more advanced abilities than our own. The hypothetical being would be worthy of respect for accomplishments far exceeding our own... but what makes that being an untouchable and unquestionable "God")

I also don't think the evidence we have supports the existence of a god and that is in fact exceedingly unlikely so: atheist (lacking faith in a god) fits as a definition as well.

I no longer think the labels are mutually exclusive.